Kieran Duff
Home Letters Handbook Order splitting Strategy funnel About Subscribe
Process · Note 018 · 12 Jun 2026

The Product Is You

If their AI software prints money, why are they selling it to you for 99 quid?

The short version
The Product Is You cover image

Seems as though the course merchants have discovered the letters AI, and suddenly everyone's "built an AI that trades for you".

Here's the tell, and it's the same tell it's always been. If the bot genuinely prints, the rational move is to run it on their own capital and never speak to you again.

I usually find that either they know it doesn't work (snake-oil), or it has zero capacity, so they know they can't scale it by putting more capital behind it.

The Economics Don't Add Up

Run the numbers on it. A real edge scales with capital. You'd trade it yourself, compound it, then raise against the verified track record, because allocators spend their lives hunting for exactly that. 99 quid a month from a few thousand subscribers is a nice little marketing business. Set it next to what a genuine edge earns compounding over a decade and the choice they've made tells you everything about what they think the bot is actually worth.

Magic Sells Better Than Maths

The AI label also does something the old "signals" couldn't: it shuts down the follow-up questions. You could interrogate a signal provider. What's the logic? What's the sample size?

An "AI agent" is a black box, and the seller wants it that way, because the whole sale runs on you not understanding it. Magic sells better than maths.

And that's what winds me up, because I build with AI every single day. It's a serious part of how I research strategies and pressure-test risk. It finds holes in my assumptions that I'd have missed. What it has never done, not once, is hand me a finished edge. The boring work is still the work: walk-forward testing, out-of-sample checks, months of live incubation before anything touches real size. The hard part of systematic trading was never writing the code.

So the grift takes a real, useful tool and wraps it around the oldest scam in the industry, because "I coded an EA and stress-tested it for months" sounds boring, and "my AI agent beats the market" sounds like you've found the enigma.

Where's The Track Record?

Ask one question and watch the story fall apart. Where's the live, third-party-verified track record, on real capital, through a real drawdown? Not a backtest.

Not a screenshot. Not a demo account. A statement.

Backtests cost nothing. Screenshots take thirty seconds in an editor. The verified statement is the one thing they can't fake, which is exactly why you never see one.

If they can't show it, the AI isn't the product. You are.

Verifiable track record first, everything else second. That hasn't changed and it never will, no matter how good the marketing gets.

Kieran Duff runs XAQP, a systematic strategy live since April 2025 with $3.7M+ in capital through Darwinex. He writes about how a systematic book is actually managed.

Disclosure. Personal commentary, not financial advice. Capital at risk. I am an employee of Darwinex; content touching Darwinex products may represent a conflict of interest, disclosed per MAR Article 20.

XAQP figures are point-in-time as of May 2026 and will change.

The Letter

Get the next letter in your inbox.

Please consider subscribing to receive more episodes of The Letter.

Subscribe now